Recent Ruling in Minnesota Shows That Tort Can Apply to Hiring Contractors
When it comes to screening contractors in Minnesota, some organizations may have operated under the belief that they had little or no liability when...
1 min read
Anti-discrimination Suit Raised Against New York Insurance Company
Verified Credentials Dec 16, 2020 12:00:00 AM
If you’re an employer that uses background reports, compliance is a priority issue. Federal, state, and local consumer reporting laws are not the only laws to consider. From ban the box to anti-discrimination, there are many other types of laws for employers to keep in mind. All are important to consider before obtaining or using a background report.
A recent lawsuit filed against the New York Life Insurance Company serves as a good reminder. The complaint alleges violations of both the New York Human Rights Law (“NYHRL”) and New York City Human Rights Law (“NYCHRL”). Let’s review what the lawsuit says.
Allegations Against New York Life
The complaint against New York Life alleges the following:
- That New York Life denied employment to qualified job applicants because of arrests that never resulted in a conviction.
- By taking adverse action based on arrests that did not result in a conviction, New York Life violated both the NYHRL and the NYCHRL. The complaint makes the claim that “both New York State and City make it per se illegal for an employer to inquire about or deny employment because of arrests that were resolved in an individual’s favor.”
- That New York Life’s practices have a negative societal effect. The complaint states that “discrimination on the basis of arrest record disproportionately impacts New Yorkers of color…”
Of course, these remain only allegations until the lawsuit is resolved. Verified Credentials will monitor this case as the litigation process goes on.
Keeping Anti-Discrimination Laws a Top Priority
Consumer reporting laws, like the FCRA, often steal the spotlight for background check compliance. Some lawsuits serve as a reminder of other compliance matters employers should care about.
In this case, the lawsuit filed against New York Life reminds employers about obligations beyond consumer reporting laws.
Monitoring and following anti-discrimination laws are just as important, as New York Life is finding out.
If you have any questions about background screening compliance, it is highly recommended that you speak with trusted legal counsel.
Clarification on New E-Verify and I-9 Compliance Requirements in Illinois
Verified Credentials: Apr 18, 2025 1:00:00 PM
Illinois first included language addressing the use of E-Verify in the Right to Privacy in the Workplace Act in 2008, with an amendment in 2010....
Oregon’s Consumer Privacy Act: 110 Complaints Filed in 6 Months
Verified Credentials: Apr 3, 2025 11:15:00 AM
In June 2023, the Oregon Legislature passed Senate Bill 619, also known as the Oregon Consumer Privacy Act (OCPA). The law took effect on July 1,...
Improper Use? Macy’s Faces Allegations of Discrimination in Background Check Policies
Verified Credentials : Nov 18, 2019 12:00:00 AM
When completing background checks, ensuring compliance with federal, state, and local consumer reporting laws is only one consideration for an...
Macy’s Learns What’s in Store for Employers Who Engage in Discriminatory Employment Practices Using Background Report Information
Verified Credentials : Sep 16, 2020 12:00:00 AM
Retail stores are no strangers to matters of civil rights. For decades, civil rights laws have helped keep retailers accountable for consumers’ civil...
Employment Discrimination Based on Criminal History: A Cautionary Tale
Verified Credentials : Jan 7, 2021 12:00:00 AM
The laws around employment background reports are vast. If you use background reports, you probably take care to follow all applicable federal,...